NCAA Hockey Recruiting FAQs Answered

Playing NCAA hockey requires more than just skill on the ice—it takes the right approach to recruitment. With college hockey coaches scouting players through junior leagues, showcases, and direct outreach, knowing how to position yourself as a strong recruit is key. From understanding scholarships and eligibility rules to creating a standout highlight video and contacting coaches, a well-planned strategy can make all the difference in earning a spot on a collegiate roster.

This FAQ guide answers the most common questions about NCAA hockey recruiting, providing a step-by-step breakdown of what you need to do to stand out, connect with the right programs, and increase your chances of playing at the next level.

Here’s what you need to know.

FAQs:

What skills do college coaches look for in recruits?

What are the average statistics or benchmarks for players at different collegiate levels (Division I, II, III)?

• Division I teams are taking players from top Junior programs.  USHL, BCHL, WHL, NAHL.  Of course there are always outliers but this is where most of the players are coming from.  The top hockey schools are taking players that produce at a higher rate. 
• Division II/III schools are still choosing from the leagues above but the less productive players.  Other lower junior hockey programs are also being watched.  
• Unless you are producing at a significant rate in Prep school if a college is interested in you they will most likely want you to play a year of juniors after you graduate.
• Some strong academic schools might also be interested in you if you have good test scores and grades. 

What tournaments or showcases should I attend to increase my visibility?

• You have to do your research.  If a specific school is interested in you and they are attending a showcase then I would tell you to attend.  Most tournaments and showcases are money makers.  I would spend a lot more time and energy working on your skill set rather than playing useless games.  
• Attending top junior hockey camps (WHL, BCHL, NAHL, USHL) might be important to get yourself noticed and to play on one of their teams.
• If you want to play Division 1 you have to play top tier juniors. 

How important are academics in the hockey recruiting process?

• College coaches want overall good people, not just good hockey players.  Academics is always important; it tells the coach what kind of person you are.  Does this player care?  Does this player give their best effort in everything they do?  Attitude, work ethic.
• Top academic schools, Ivies, are looking for good students.     

What is the role of junior hockey leagues in college recruitment?

• Junior hockey leagues are taking over the college recruitment process.  Coaches want older, matured players coming into their hockey programs.

What should I expect during an official visit to a college campus?

• The assistant coach or the head coach will take you around the campus.  He will ask you questions such as why are you interested in our program or what makes you want to come to our school.  It is also a good time to get to know eachother better.  You should come prepared with some questions that you have about athletics and academics.

How can I assess if a college program is the right fit for me?

• Do you feel wanted by the coach?  Have you attended the campus and seen what it has to offer you?  Have you done research on your own about the school?  Do you have friends that have attended and have asked them about it?  I would advise to ask a lot of questions to a lot of different people.  Do you research!  Does it feel right to you in your heart?  I think it should be a place you are excited about attending.

How do I balance showcasing my individual skills while being a team player during evaluations?

• Good players make their teammates better.  Do you have a good attitude?  Hockey is a team sport.  You need your teammates and they need you.  Hockey is a game where you can showcase your ability (Skating, Shooting, Hockey Sense) along with being a team player.  I think it is pretty clear when a player is doing the opposite, being selfish, and only trying to showcase themself.     

About the Author: Brandon, Athletic Strategy Hockey Specialist

Brandon McNally is a former Dartmouth College hockey standout and professional player who now mentors young athletes through the NCAA recruitment process. At Dartmouth, he played four seasons, recording 31 goals and 34 assists in 106 games. As a freshman, he led all ECAC and Ivy League rookies in goals during conference play, earning Rookie of the Month honors. His talent earned him NHL development camp invites from the Tampa Bay Lightning and Montreal Canadiens.

After graduation, Brandon signed a professional contract with the Hamilton Bulldogs (AHL) and later played for the St. John’s IceCaps (Montreal Canadiens affiliate) before continuing his career in Italy, Sweden, Denmark, Great Britain, and Japan. He currently competes in Japan and represents the Italian National Hockey Team in World Championship events.

Beyond playing, Brandon is a European scout for a Swedish team and an American hockey instructor, specializing in skating, skills development, and film analysis. As a Crimson Hockey Strategist, he helps athletes refine their game, training approach, and recruitment strategy. Passionate about player development, Brandon provides clear, actionable steps to help athletes maximize their strengths, improve weaknesses, and take ownership of their recruiting journey.